We’ve combed through the historic district and the quiet side streets to curate a list of five exceptional, highly-rated, and deeply beloved local spots. From fresh-caught Atlantic seafood to immersive Peruvian fine dining, here are the standout places to eat and drink in St. Augustine.

As the oldest continuously occupied European-established settlement within the borders of the continental United States, every cobblestone, coquina wall, and ocean breeze in St. Augustine feels heavy with centuries of history.